| Set 1 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Can't Take Our Love Away > | Song Stats | ||
| Californ-i-a (Jeffrey Foucault) | Song Stats | Only Time Played | |
| Hey Ruth | Song Stats | ||
| Surabaya Santa (Jessica Molaskey) | With Mandy on Vox | Song Stats | Only Time Played |
| Ithaca (Peter Mulvey) | With Tom on Vox | Song Stats | |